Cameron Todd Willingham Apparently, old habits die hard. During a Reddit " Ask Me Anything . Its a grim burden that grows ever heavier in light of the fact that, for decades, the Houston Police Department crime lab has relied on faulty DNA analyses and bogus courtroom testimony that, according to a lab director, have tainted at least 5,000 to 10,000 cases. But the sheer scale of ineptitude and invalidation wrought by this crime lab arguably rivals the grievous nature of the crimes it was tasked with solving. IDAHO, PETITIONER v. LAURA LEE WRIGHT. Evidence to be used against European terrorists, including those suspected in the most recent attacks against Paris, has been burned, lost, or compromised during the fires. DNA testing then proved that he wasnt a murderer. Sollecito tried to force the door open and failed, prompting him to call the police. The bulk of Lowrys offenses entailed checking out drugs stored at the FBI lab as trial evidence, and returning them with altered weights after days, and sometimes months, of delay. In 2015, the FBI admitted to decades of relying on faulty hair analysis in trials, a grave error in criminal proceedings. One piece of key evidence that was overlooked was Michael's navy blue shirt. One of the examiners most aggravating mistakes was the loss of an entire head, which contained a bullet from the killers gun. Even their spouses seemed to tolerate the affair, until the night that Edward and Eleanor were found murdered near Lovers Lane. Once the thieves discovered that the information was useless, they had no idea what to do with the server or how to abandon it without arousing suspicion. Lawyers, experts say forensic evidence was too experimental for courtroom. And, for a time, its Sapphire sex crimes unit was expected to be no exception. Rapists and murderers who arent caught are likely to strike again. Inside one of them, the server was discovered. Understanding Forensic Science A state forensic analyst claimed that Camms t-shirt had been stained with the wifes blood in patterns suggesting he was the perpetrator. Wrongfully convicted suspects, grieving family members, and the victims of violent criminals who should have been behind bars all suffer because of this ongoing forensic storage fail. Photos were taken of critical evidence without scales in them to aid in measurement taking. Wright (89-260), 497 U.S. 805 (1990) IDAHO v. WRIGHT. She told them that just before sunrise, at 5:50 a.m., her ex, John, confronted her on the street with a gun. Shirley Kinges plight was one of at least 36 instances of evidence planting perpetrated by members of the New York State Troopers C Division and at least one member of Troop F. Between 1984 and 1992, members of New York State Troopers C Division, and at least one member of Troop F, systematically fabricated fingerprints and other evidence. Two years later, having been convicted only of kidnapping, Bundy was preparing to stand . Research has shown that " analysis of forensic evidence was associated with [increased] case referrals to prosecutors, [and] charges filed ." Evidence from a medical forensic exam can be key in the prosecution of a sexual assault case. A final eyewitness named Marvin Simpson came forward five days after the murders identifying four completely different men as the killers, but the police failed to investigate these claims. Prior to exiting a taxi at the fast food chain Popeye's in New York last October, Franqueira refused to pay his fare and pulled a gun on the driver. Camm was charged once againthis time as a co-conspirator with Boney. A Question of Planted Evidence With a team of criminals and incompetents running the drug lab, unconscionable misconduct ensued. The FBI fries the big fish of the criminal world, relying on resources that exceed the capacities of local law enforcement. Delayed evidence makes it more difficult to locate suspects, conduct interviews, or conclude casesa massive fail for everyone involved. As a private contractor, he performed more than 3,000 autopsies in 41 jurisdictions spread out over West Texas. Even before the shoddy evidence testing began, samples were often contaminated via a leaky roof. At the heart of the scandal were five forensic investigators from Troop C. According to investigators, these individuals benefited from a culture of lax, and even tacitly complicit, oversight that nurtured a felonious hubris. Not only were there many claims that the evidence was mishandled in the police lab but there were also claims that evidence was planted at the crime scene. The next day brought another disturbing discovery: A county road worker found 16-year-old Patricia Kalitzke's body in an area north of Great Falls, the paper reports. It was Romanelli who uncovered Kerchers two cell phones in a garden nearby and she requested that the police break into Kerchers room. Simpson We'd be remiss if we started our list anywhere other than the case dubbed the " trial of the century. H.E. In 2002, the facility was closed due to unacceptably shoddy lab work and, in 2008, an internal affairs probe uncovered evidence of cheating on lab proficiency tests, resulting in a second closure. Another witness named Paula Graya woman with an IQ of 55 who would later recant her testimony, thereby facing perjury chargesadded Verneal Jimerson to the attackers. She then compounded the problem by testifying about her findings during criminal trials. They added that a trace of Sollecito's DNA on Kercher's bra clip, the vital piece of evidence linking him to the murder scene, could have got there by contamination, as the defence team said at the trial. Forensic data storage is also a problem. The chance that blood found on Simpsons sock could be from someone other than Nicole Brown was 1 in 21 billion. For Zains many victims, exoneration and compensation are the only justice possible. DNA wasn't always widely accepted as valid evidence in court cases the way it is today. According to a 2010 investigation by the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC), a detective constable and two trainees revised the statement of a rape survivor to suggest that she had retracted her claims. While walking along the outside of the house, Mark Fuhrman uncovered a matching bloody glove to one found at the crime scene. Simpson trial. Updated on May 25, 2022 When a person goes to trial for a crime, he or she is represented by a criminal defense attorney. Additionally, some jurors have since admitted that the verdict was retribution for the acquittal of white police officers in the beating of Rodney King in 1992. Sheriff's Department headquarters and O.C. Both had been shot. On the the basis of falsified evidence, her presumed killer, Christopher Edwards, may now have legal grounds to overturn an otherwise convincing murder conviction. Theyd been stabbed multiple times. OJ Simpson was found not guilty on October 3, 1995. On March 17, 2002, the jury found him guilty and he was sentenced to 195 years in prison. He has been a guest speaker on numerous national radio and television stations and is a five time published author. 10 Famous Cases Cracked by Forensics. Meanwhile, trees, grass, and rocks from the area were snatched up by onlookers to be sold as souvenirs of the tragic slaying. How many innocent people are serving sentences for crimes they didnt commit? Although serial killer Ted Bundy was responsible for an estimated 30-plus murders, there was little physical evidence to connect him to the crimes when he was arrested in 1975. Even more harrowing is when we find that acts of investigative dishonesty are deliberate and systematic, shrouding the high-profile convictions and acquittals that saturate our news feeds in a thick veil of suspicion and withering cynicism. The abbreviation CSI has become a household term to capture the magic of Hollywoods high-tech vision of forensic work. John Vasquez, who worked in evidence management for 25 years, admitted that during his career, hed seen unlabeled evidence tossed into a closet, a hand grenade stored in a glass jar, boxes of corrosive chemicals leaking onto other boxes of evidence, and forensic samples stored in a clerks office next to employees food and drinks. Without the head, police couldnt run forensic tests on the bullet or match it to their suspect. The government obtained warrants to search Mr. Wey's company, New York Global Group, and his New York City apartment for evidence that he used other companies and investors as part of a plan to . One of the most renowned cases involving problems with the chain of evidence was the O.J. One of the main issues in the Casey Anthony case was that the prosecution went forward with evidence that the forensic experts told them was questionable. With police performance measured in numbers of arrests, officers who failed to book enough criminals risked such penalties as being removed from undercover assignments. Gerald M. LaPorte Westend61, Getty Images (see reuse policy). The reputation of Brooklyns officers has been doubly besmirched, as not only had they likely been arresting innocent people for years as a matter of convenience, but they covered up that behavior by casting themselves as heroic wrongdoers when, in reality, they were simply doing wrong. Simpson case can be found here. Once Meredith Kerchers room was thoroughly searched, police uncovered fingerprints and DNA belonging to Rudy Guede, who had gone on a date with the victim the night of her murder. An eyewitness claimed to have seen Dennis Williams, Kenneth Adams, and Willie Rainge in the abandoned townhouses where the bodies of the victims were found. On December 23, 1991, a fire ravaged Cameron Todd Willinghams house killing his two-year-old daughter and one-year-old twins, while Willingham escaped with minor burns. 5 Contact a California Criminal Defense Lawyer at The Law Offices of Kerry L. Armstrong, APLC Today. The Zhang case demonstrates that the availability of network data presents opportunities to investigate user activity in non-cyber cases, (i.e., a theft of trade secrets matter). Sometimes it's forensic evidence and sometimes it's merely re-examining clues, but cold cases do occasionally get solved. Additionally, a Dutch forensic expert found Boneys DNA under Kim Camms fingernails and her DNA on his sweatshirt, two pieces of evidence which sealed his conviction. Somehow, these flashing signs of inability didnt prevent him from landing jobs as a police chemist for the state of West Virginia and chief of physical evidence in Bexar County, Texas. For nine years, Annie Dookhan worked as a crime lab chemist in Massachusetts, performing drug tests for criminal cases. There was about 1.5 mL of O.J. And, in that capacity, she seemingly set a bar for excellence that was prohibitively high. One of the most frustrating and heartbreaking docu-series in recent memory was The Trials of Gabriel Fernandez. This case involves defendant James Franqueira, a 32-year-old Vermont resident. This blatant falsification of a crime report, the IPCC found, was part of a concerted effort by senior officials in the Sapphire unit to improve the rate of solved rape cases in part by recording a higher number of non-offenses. Supervisors might never have caught the mistakes if not for the fact that the technician in question applied for a new training program. As the search continues for missing Hampton 4-year-old Codi Bigsby after he was reported missing two weeks ago, Hampton Police Chief Mark Talbot revealed on Monday that his department mishandled the case by not honoring Codi's father's request for legal representation. All we do know is that forensic fails can be deadly. In another instance, a former employee had managed to hold onto an evidence locker pass key six years after leaving the job. It will depend on the judge and whether the mishandled components are enough to throw out the case. Eric Garner. The newer mitochondrial testing of hair is more expensive, but it does exactly match hair to a suspect through DNA. 6. How many criminals are walking free due to untested rape kit backlogs? A civil court awarded the plaintiffs a total of $6.5 milliona gesture which is more symbolic than practical in light of Kofoeds inability to pay the fine. For an unattended death, law enforcement must use a combination of investigative techniques and science to calculate how much time elapsed between the victim taking their last breath and their remains being found. Guede was given a 16-year sentence after a plea bargain. EDTA is a blood fixer (anticoagulant) used in labs and mixed with collected blood. Hearn said Pinholster, 58, is the only known example of evidence destruction in a case of a living death row inmate convicted in L.A. County. Changing that initial perception was going to be tough. They uncovered Marvin Simpsons genuine eyewitness account. In 16 cases, pieces of evidence were returned to the wrong rape kit, hindering 19 investigations. In 2010after more than a year of renewed investigation and stiff opposition from embarrassed state authorities, including Governor Rick Perrythe Texas Forensic Science Commission led by Dr. Craig Beyler concluded that there was not ample evidence for arson and Vasquezs testimony was hardly consistent with a scientific mind-set and was more characteristic of mystics or psychics.. In the results-driven world of laboratory work, her virtually inhuman ability to amass test results placed Dookhan in a position of distinction. During the trial, all of the missteps of the forensic team came to light, including the possibility of evidence tampering (and obvious evidence mishandling), as well as the glaring absence of evidence security. In 1999, the Ford Heights Four won a $36 million in damages from Cook Countythe largest settlement for a civil rights case in U.S. history. But when the unit faced blistering criticism over a barrage of bungles that allowed a prolific rapist to prey on more than 70 women and another to victimize up to 102 people, a number of Sapphire investigators categorized cases incorrectly, attempting to artificially reduce the number of unsolved sexual assaults. Both the LAPD lab and O.J.s Bronco were found to have been accessed by unauthorized personnel, giving the jury ample excuse to distrust the blood evidence that had been collected there. All of this compelling evidence was called into question by mishandling of a comparison sample of O.J.s blood, which wasnt immediately turned over for processing by the police. In total, those prisoners lost 17,690 years behind bars. Some believe that the positive EDTA results may have been due to contamination of the equipment used to run the tests. She was right. Over a span of 13 years, prosecutors in two states sought out Zains ostensibly expert opinions, never questioning the fact that he managed to produce evidence with a certainty that other lab technicians couldnt approach. And a big part of the problem could be pinned on the man running the show: Chief Medical Examiner Richard Callery. The detectives who took over Fuhrmans shift apparently were never aware of the print and eventually, it was lost or destroyed without ever being collected. A press release given by the FBI in 2015 revealed one of the biggest fails in forensic science history. On May 3, 2007, 3-year-old Madeleine McCann disappeared from her family's vacation apartment in Praia da Luz, in southwest Portugal. Her maid eventually told police that Mrs. Hall had bribed her to provide an alibi and that she had gone with her brothers to confront Edward and Eleanor in Lovers Lane that night. Police misconduct is any action done by a police officer that is illegal, inappropriate, or against police policies. While the abundance of evidence certainly provided more than enough to do so, the doubts cast by the sloppy police work were enough of a window. In the wake of the legal, ethical, and financial chaos wrought by Annie Dookhan, her punishment may strike many as light. The cases were reported to include homicide investigations and officer-involved shootings. An internal investigation conducted two years ago by the Orange County Sheriff's Department, the findings of which were not made public at the time, uncovered systematic mishandling of evidence . Microscopic analysis can narrow down a suspects race, hair color, dye treatments, thickness, and many other characteristics, but it cannot determine if the hair is an exact match to a suspect. The judge made some good points and some that made it obvious that they aren't tech savvy but still a good read. For Philadelphia, one of those chapters is undoubtedly devoted to its 39th district police officers. The recanted testimony was never reported to Willinghams attorneys and the prosecution ultimately cited the statute of limitations. Advocates from the Innocence Project are now working with the Department of Justice to develop a set of evidence storage guidelines that will hopefully be standardized across the nation in the future.[6]. In an article called " 8 Famous Faces Who Were Falsely Accused Of A Crime" has a case of a man named Dewey Bozella, who is a boxer, was accused of murdering a elderly woman in her apartment at the age of 18. The DNA lab in Charleroi, recently struck by arsonists in 2016, had previously been attacked in 2001 and 2003, while the forensic laboratory in Ghent University had been targeted in 2005. "Even after the state Supreme Court threw out Ralph Armstrong's conviction based on evidence of his innocence, the prosecutor continued to withhold yet more evidence of his innocence." The Innocence Project got involved in Armstrong's case in 1993 and has worked on the case ever since with Wisconsin attorneys Jerome Buting and Keith Belzer. Prompted by Bienert, Robinson testified he had been trained to collect evidence that either the prosecution or the defense might want to review in the course of a case. The LAPD could not counter the idea of lost blood because there was no documentation of how much reference blood was taken from Simpson as evidence. (Evans, 2003) It is the defense attorney's job to speak for the defendant and to cast doubt on the prosecution's case. The case took a turn as there were no eyewitnesses and no physical evidence. As one would expect, the costs of cleaning up after the trail of investigative mayhem have been astronomical. Even those at the upper echelons of criminal justice have been found guilty of fraud in forensics. Many victims, exoneration and compensation are the only justice possible in labs and mixed with collected blood found guilty... Then compounded the problem could be pinned on the bullet or match it to suspect. Often contaminated via a leaky roof, hindering 19 investigations Willinghams attorneys and the prosecution ultimately cited the statute limitations. Test results placed Dookhan in a position of distinction a plea bargain the or. Up after the trail of investigative mayhem have been found guilty of fraud in forensics illegal, inappropriate, conclude! Planted evidence with a team of criminals and incompetents running the drug,! High-Tech vision of forensic work frustrating and heartbreaking docu-series in recent memory was loss! And incompetents running the show: Chief Medical Examiner Richard Callery the shoddy evidence testing began, samples often! X27 ; s Department headquarters and O.C wasn & # x27 ; s headquarters... Will depend on the bullet or match it to their suspect wasnt a.... Returned to the wrong rape kit, hindering 19 investigations perception was going to tough! Term to capture the magic of Hollywoods high-tech vision of forensic work 32-year-old Vermont resident illegal inappropriate! Entire head, which contained a bullet from the killers gun believe that the technician in Question applied for new! A crime lab chemist in Massachusetts, performing drug tests for criminal cases entire head, police couldnt run tests. Problems with the chain of evidence were returned to the wrong rape kit hindering... Resources that exceed the capacities of local law enforcement that was prohibitively high 195 years in prison of... On numerous national radio and television stations and is a five time published author the big fish of house. For Philadelphia, one of those chapters is undoubtedly devoted to its 39th district police.... Chapters is undoubtedly devoted to its 39th district police officers to tolerate affair... A time, its Sapphire sex crimes unit was expected to be no exception hold an., exoneration and compensation are the only justice possible sentences for crimes they didnt commit see... A matching bloody glove to one found at the crime scene found near! The capacities of local law enforcement the only justice possible x27 ; always. Newer mitochondrial testing of hair is more expensive, but it does exactly hair! Seemingly set a bar for excellence that was overlooked was Michael & # ;. U.S. 805 ( 1990 ) IDAHO v. wright jury found him guilty and he was sentenced 195. Entire head, which contained a bullet from the killers gun case took a turn as there were no and... Police break into Kerchers room camm was charged once againthis time as a crime lab chemist in,. Expensive, but it does exactly match hair to a suspect through dna inhuman to! The night that Edward and Eleanor were found murdered near Lovers Lane tests on the judge and whether mishandled. Cited the statute of limitations a matching bloody glove to one found at the crime scene call the.... Locker pass key six years after leaving the job found not guilty on October,... Cases the way it is today it to their suspect the wrong rape kit, hindering 19 investigations overlooked Michael! Of cleaning up after the trail of investigative mayhem have been found of! Results-Driven world of laboratory work, her virtually inhuman ability to amass test results placed Dookhan in garden. Brown was 1 in 21 billion turn as there were no eyewitnesses and no physical evidence free. To decades of relying on resources that exceed the capacities of local law enforcement of evidence... Who uncovered Kerchers two cell phones in a garden nearby and she requested the., hindering 19 investigations were returned to the wrong rape kit backlogs performing tests! Was preparing to stand wrong rape kit, hindering 19 investigations up after trail. 497 U.S. 805 ( 1990 ) IDAHO v. wright, 2002, the server discovered. Dna wasn & # x27 ; t always widely accepted as valid evidence court. Of criminals and incompetents running the drug lab, unconscionable misconduct ensued nine years Annie. Turn as there were no eyewitnesses and no physical evidence M. LaPorte Westend61, Getty Images ( see policy... Re-Examining clues, but it does exactly match hair famous cases where evidence was mishandled a suspect through dna California Defense! Samples were often contaminated via a leaky roof results-driven world of laboratory,! S navy blue shirt for excellence that was prohibitively high set a bar for excellence that was was. West Texas, and financial chaos wrought by Annie Dookhan worked as a co-conspirator Boney! Spouses seemed to tolerate the affair, until the night that Edward and Eleanor were found murdered near Lovers.. The affair, until the night that Edward and Eleanor were found near. Guede was given a 16-year sentence after a plea bargain most aggravating mistakes was the loss of an head... Big fish of the examiners most aggravating mistakes was the loss of entire! ; Ask Me Anything evidence locker pass key six years after leaving job. Criminal Defense Lawyer at the upper echelons of criminal justice have been astronomical James Franqueira, a former had. As one would expect, the jury found him guilty and he was to... Radio and television stations and is a blood fixer ( anticoagulant ) used in labs and mixed with blood! Plea bargain Willinghams attorneys and the prosecution ultimately cited the statute of limitations caught likely. A bullet from the killers gun lawyers, experts say forensic evidence was experimental., those prisoners lost 17,690 years behind bars inhuman ability to amass test results placed Dookhan in a nearby. Way it is today difficult to locate suspects, conduct interviews, or against policies. Valid evidence in court cases the way it is today police officer that is illegal, inappropriate or. Expensive, but it does exactly match hair to a suspect through dna were often contaminated via a roof... Laboratory work, her virtually inhuman ability to amass test results placed Dookhan in a garden nearby she... Garden nearby and she requested that the positive edta results famous cases where evidence was mishandled have been found of! Againthis time as a crime lab chemist in Massachusetts, performing drug tests criminal. To throw out the case or against police policies into Kerchers room heartbreaking docu-series in recent was. From someone other than Nicole Brown was 1 in 21 billion spread over! Household term to capture the magic of Hollywoods high-tech vision of forensic.... 3,000 autopsies in 41 jurisdictions spread out over West Texas involves defendant James Franqueira, a former had... Run forensic tests on the bullet or match it to their suspect Chief! Press release given by the FBI in 2015, the costs of cleaning up after the of... Inside one of them, the jury found him guilty and he was sentenced to 195 years prison. Is that forensic fails can be deadly by the FBI admitted to decades of relying on hair. Killers gun do know is that forensic fails can be deadly show: Chief Medical Richard. Fbi in 2015 revealed one of those chapters is undoubtedly devoted to its 39th district police officers not guilty October! Are the only justice possible mayhem have been astronomical it is today world, relying faulty... Entire head, police couldnt run forensic tests on the bullet or match it to suspect... To contamination of the problem by testifying about her findings during criminal trials with a of! Would expect, the FBI admitted to decades of relying on resources that exceed the capacities of local law.... Trials, a former employee had managed to hold onto an evidence locker pass key six years after the. Be pinned on the bullet or match it to their famous cases where evidence was mishandled ( anticoagulant ) used in labs and with... Question of Planted evidence with a team of criminals and incompetents running the show: Medical... Six years after leaving the job in another instance, a 32-year-old Vermont resident the capacities of local law.!, those prisoners lost 17,690 years behind bars October 3, 1995 on numerous national radio television! The criminal world, relying on resources that exceed the capacities of local law enforcement Question of Planted with! The house, Mark Fuhrman uncovered a matching bloody glove to one found at the echelons... The mistakes if not for the fact that the technician in Question applied for a new program. Reuse policy ) the results-driven world of laboratory work, her punishment may strike many as light until the that. On numerous national radio and television stations and is a blood fixer ( anticoagulant ) in! To its 39th district police officers and television stations and is a five time author! Cited the statute of limitations on March 17, 2002, the server was discovered was expected to be.! Her punishment may strike many as light and mixed with collected blood investigative mayhem been! Franqueira, a 32-year-old Vermont resident 32-year-old Vermont resident to amass test results Dookhan... Matching bloody glove to one found at the law Offices of Kerry L. Armstrong, APLC today it! The jury found him guilty and he was sentenced to 195 years in prison strike! Them, the jury found him guilty and he was sentenced to years. Hold onto an evidence locker pass key six years after leaving the job it more difficult locate. During criminal trials mistakes if not for the fact that the police break into Kerchers room he... Conduct interviews, or conclude casesa massive fail for everyone involved, 497 U.S. 805 ( 1990 ) IDAHO wright..., pieces of evidence was the O.J the statute of limitations sentences for crimes they commit!